Two recent incidents, Murthy and national anthem and Tendulkar and national flag, refreshed my memories on how over-sensitive and under-confident as a nation we are. Narayana Murthy, the chairman of Infosys, and his critics alike are blissfully unaware of how much they share in common. Murthy is under heavy criticism for his remarks that only an instrumental version of the national anthem was played at a recent function organized by his company because “foreign employees present would have been embarrassed at their ignorance of the lyric”. What can be more symptomatic of a complete lack of self-assurance than the fact that a self-made billionaire, founder of one of the fastest growing InfoTech companies in the world and an icon of India’s economic rise, felt ashamed at singing Indian national anthem at an Indian location, and that on the occasion of visit of the Indian President?
His critics, the so called nationalist forces, have been so outraged at this suggestion that they have launched a campaign against him. Karnataka Police is investigating the matter and the Honorable Home Minister of Karnataka has promised a legal action against him. What a shame! Here is a man who made a tactless remark. He did not insult the national anthem. He cannot be accused of crime or treason. If at all, he can be blamed for is, is the fact that despite all his achievements in life, he still remains an under-confident man. Perhaps a man who is still trapped in an inferiority complex inherited from our colonial past; and a man who still feels the need to bend to the pleasure of white race.
But, that is not a crime. That is a symptom of a disease. And lest his critics feel vindicated or superior, let me state it squarely and boldly, if he suffers from this disease, so do the rest of us. If not, why do we find it so hard to shrug the incident aside? Are we trying to find a scapegoat for our own inner frustrations? Are we not trying to put blame on one person and feel superior? What is the need to be so sensitive to any sign of weakness in other person?
After every minor success, we feel the need to project ourselves as world powers; and after every failure, we start baying for blood. If we win a cricket tournament, we become world champions. If we lose a tournament, we feel we are the worst team in the world. Winning one silver medal at the Olympics is enough to send the entire nation into mass hysteria. One Indian company acquires a foreign company and we go into frenzy: India the next global economic power shouts our media. Try running a Google search on “India and superpower”, and you will be surprised to see over a million hits. Counter that with the reality. We are unable to manage our tiny neighbors. We are a home to the world’s largest population of hungry and illiterate people. The diseases, that have been conquered everywhere else in the world, flourish among us. Dowry and female infanticide are our specialties and caste-based distinctions our proud reality. Our sports, notwithstanding our population of over a billion, suck.
If India had been winning at the Cricket World Cup, we would not be incensed at our “beloved” cricketers cutting a cake that had our flag’s tri-color on it. But, since they lost out to the minnows, our indignation knows no bounds.
The fact is that as a nation we are so short on successes that we are given to mass hysteria over whatever little comes our way. And if some incident reminds us of our inadequacies and failure, our sensitivities are triggered to an extent that we lose our sense of proportions. Our sensitivities, to me, are symptoms of a paucity of successes and a collective lack of confidence. We are so scared of facing up to our real problems that our feelings are ventilated in our “righteous” anger over non-issues.
Yes, forget hunger, disease, missing girls, bonded labor, suppression, and human rights. They are all minor irritants. Let us focus on Narayana Murthy and his foolish remarks. Let us focus on whether a cake should have national colors on it. Let us focus on whether we can wear T-shirts with pictures of national flags on them. Nowhere else in the world have I seen people plagued with such enormous maladies occupied with such trivial pursuits! No wonder we are the under-achievers of the world. No wonder we are so unsure of ourselves.
What a waste of time and talent! Go back and resume your great debate, if you must. Else ask your leaders to focus on real issues, not trivial distractions.
Punit Arora is an expert on management and public policy in developing countries. He can be reached at pun8max@gmail.com