The news of scandal has recently rocked the $7 trillion mutual fund industry. If you own a mutual fund, are wondering how this might affect you and what action you should take, read on.
Many of the recent charges relate to a practice known as late trading. Mutual fund orders have to be placed by 4 p.m. Eastern time in order to receive that day’s closing price. If an order is received after the cut-off, it can’t be processed until the following day.
But with late trading, selected orders received after the cut-off are still given same-day status. Some mutual fund companies allowed a select few to do this and then went to great lengths to cover up these trades. This is clearly illegal and those involved should be severely punished.
Market timing is another practice being scrutinized. Traders buy and sell mutual fund shares based on small changes in the prices of a fund’s underlying stocks that aren’t currently reflected in the fund’s share price. This is most often done with international stock mutual funds, because of the delay in the close of overseas markets and those in the U.S. Market timing itself is not illegal. But some mutual funds stated in their prospectus that they did not allow such trading, but secretly allowed it anyway for certain investors.
The effect of both of these practices is that they allowed a privileged few to profit while in effect lowering the overall returns for the large number of smaller, longer term investors. The willful deception of shareholders by the fund management is inexcusable.
It’s important to keep these charges in perspective. First, the underlying value of the stocks in these mutual funds has not been affected. This isn’t like Enron where you could see your investment drop 80% simply because of the scandal. Second, the market timing charges are mostly limited to international funds. Third, so far only a few fund companies are affected. And last, mutual funds in general still remain an excellent investment vehicle.
What should you do if you are in one of the mutual funds named in this scandal? You might want to consider getting out of that fund and that fund company altogether. But getting out might be difficult if you face a stiff penalty or recently paid a big commission when you purchased it.
In this case, you’d have to weigh the cost of liquidation against the level of your concern. If moving out of the fund family altogether proves too costly, you can at least move ‘sideways’ into a less-affected fund in the same fund family.
If you are trapped in a fund family because of commissions or penalties, you should probably find a different advisor. My clients don’t have to pay big commissions or face stiff surrender penalties on their investments and neither should you! It is completely unnecessary and it severely limits your ability to quickly make changes when needed.
You might also consider alternatives to investing in mutual funds. For instance, Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) provide the diversification of a mutual fund but are actively traded like a stock, which means they can be bought or sold any time during the day. ETFs are designed to mimic an underlying index and since they are not actively managed, they have very low internal fees.
Several things are certain about the current mutual fund scandal. More affected companies will be named in the weeks and months ahead. Criminal and civil charges will continue to be filed. Class action suits are sure to follow. New regulations will be discussed to keep such illegal activities from reoccurring.
The jury is still out on how all of this will affect you. Hopefully some positive reforms will result, but regulators have a tendency to overreact and create solutions that in the end do more harm than good. Stay informed, keep an eye on your funds, and be prepared to make adjustments so you can stay on track to meet your goals.
If you have questions or are concerned about the funds you are invested in and would like my opinion on your specific situation, free of charge, let me know. It’s your money and you need to make sure it is protected.
Mr. Voudrie is a Certified Financial Planner and President of Legacy Planning Group, Inc., a Private Wealth Management Firm in Johnson City, TN. He can be reached toll-free at 1-877-827-1463 or at jeff@guardingyourwealth.com
Nationally-syndicated financial columnist and Certified Financial Planner® Jeffrey Voudrie provides personal, in-depth money management services and advice to select private clients throughout the USA. He’ll answer your financial question – FREE at http://www.guardingyourwealth.com